On the Record: The Beatles - Yesterday and Today - The Butcher Cover
Share
Welcome back to “On the Record,” where we uncover the fascinating stories behind the rarest and most collectible vinyl records. Today, we’re diving into the world of rock 'n' roll royalty with a focus on one of the most iconic bands in history: The Beatles. Let’s explore their most rare and sought-after vinyl record.
The Album: "Yesterday and Today" - The Butcher Cover
The Beatles' "Yesterday and Today" is one of the most famous and controversial records in music history, primarily due to its original cover, known as the "Butcher Cover." Released in 1966 by Capitol Records in the United States, the album featured a provocative cover image that was quickly withdrawn, making it an incredibly rare find for collectors.
The Story Behind the Vinyl
The original cover of "Yesterday and Today" featured the band dressed in butcher smocks, covered in raw meat and dismembered baby dolls. This imagery was intended as a satirical commentary on the band's treatment by the record company, but it caused an immediate backlash. Capitol Records quickly recalled the album and replaced the cover with a more conventional image of the band around a trunk.
The recalled copies with the original "Butcher Cover" were supposed to be destroyed, but some were salvaged by employees and collectors, making them extremely rare. There are three known states of the "Butcher Cover":
- First State: Original unaltered cover
- Second State: Original cover with a replacement cover pasted over it (these can be "peeled" to reveal the butcher image underneath)
- Third State: Covers that have been peeled to reveal the butcher image
Collectability and Value
The "Butcher Cover" is one of the most sought-after and valuable Beatles records. As of 2024, first-state copies in mint condition can fetch anywhere from $15,000 to over $250,000, depending on the condition and provenance. Second- and third-state copies are also highly prized, with prices varying based on the quality of the peel job and overall condition.
The value of this record is driven by its rarity, the controversy surrounding its release, and the enduring popularity of The Beatles. Collectors are willing to pay a premium for copies with original shrink wrap and unpeeled second-state covers.
How to Spot a Genuine Copy
Given the high value of "Yesterday and Today" with the "Butcher Cover," ensuring the authenticity of a copy is crucial. Here are some tips:
- Check the Cover: For first-state covers, look for the original butcher image. For second-state covers, examine the replacement cover for signs of a butcher cover underneath, such as visible seams or slight bumps.
- Examine the Labels: Authentic copies will have the correct Capitol Records labels and catalog numbers (T 2553 for mono, ST 2553 for stereo).
- Look for Serial Numbers: Genuine pressings will have unique serial numbers etched into the run-out grooves.
- Purchase from Reputable Sources: Always buy from trusted sellers or certified record stores to avoid counterfeit copies.
Conclusion
The Beatles' "Yesterday and Today" with the "Butcher Cover" is more than just a vinyl record—it’s a piece of rock history. Its rarity, combined with the story behind its controversial cover, makes it a treasure for both die-hard Beatles fans and serious collectors. Whether you’re a Beatles enthusiast or a vinyl aficionado, this record is a testament to the enduring appeal of physical music formats in the digital age.
Stay tuned for more deep dives into the fascinating stories behind the rarest records out there, right here on “On the Record” at Heathen Records. And remember, if you ever come across this vinyl, consider yourself lucky—you’ve found a true gem.
Looking for more rare and collectible vinyl? Visit Heathen Records to explore our curated selection of the finest records from around the world. Happy collecting!